Portrait of Asbjorn Bjaanes
Asbjorn Bjaanes

Articles ·

All Decisions Are Emotional — Why Teams Must Learn to Shift Perspectives

All Decisions Are Emotional — Why Teams Must Learn to Shift Perspectives

We like to think of ourselves as rational decision-makers. Leaders, teams, and organizations often pride themselves on logic, data, and well-structured arguments. Yet, neuroscience tells a different story.

At the core, all decisions are emotional. Logic is what we use to justify or validate decisions after our emotional brain has already made them.

The Hidden Emotional Layer Behind Every Choice

Antonio Damasio, a leading neuroscientist, famously showed that when people have damage to the emotional centers of their brain, they struggle to make even basic decisions — even though their logic remains intact. Why? Because emotion gives value to options.

Without emotion, everything is just neutral data. The “gut feeling” that pushes us toward or away from a decision is the emotional filter that assigns meaning to information. Whether we admit it or not, we feel before we think.

In teams, this plays out every day:

  • A team member pushes back on an idea — not because of the data, but because they feel unheard.
  • A leader clings to a strategy — not because it’s optimal, but because it feels safe or familiar.
  • Teams reach consensus — not always because of logic, but because it emotionally feels “good enough” to move forward.

Understanding this is critical for leaders, Scrum Masters, and anyone facilitating decision-making.

Why Logic Alone Fails in Teams

In high-pressure situations, we often default to:

  • Presenting more data.
  • Creating stronger arguments.
  • Applying structured frameworks to analyze.

While these tools have value, they only work if the emotional layer has been addressed first. Without aligning emotions within the team, logic often falls flat or, worse, deepens the divide.

The Power of the 3 Perceptual Positions

This is where the 3 Perceptual Positions from NLP can be a game-changer for team decision-making.

The model invites us to step into three distinct perspectives:

1️⃣ 1st Position — Self (Me)

This is your default viewpoint: your needs, your emotions, your story. In decision-making, this often sounds like:

  • “I believe this is the right choice.”
  • “I feel uncomfortable moving forward.”

Many team conflicts get stuck here because everyone is locked into defending their own emotional investment.

2️⃣ 2nd Position — Other (You)

Stepping into the other person’s shoes shifts the lens. It’s about:

  • “How does this person feel about this situation?”
  • “What emotional needs might they have behind their position?”

This perspective fosters empathy. It moves teams from judgment (“they’re wrong”) to understanding (“they’re protecting something important to them”).

3️⃣ 3rd Position — Observer (The System)

This is the neutral, systemic viewpoint — the meta-position. From here, you detach emotionally and view the interaction like an outsider:

  • “What emotional patterns or blind spots are emerging in this team dynamic?”
  • “What’s really influencing this decision beyond the words and data?”

How to Apply This Model for Better Team Decisions

1. Acknowledge the emotional drivers early. Don’t shy away from emotions in decision-making. Bring them to the surface. A simple question like “What’s important to you about this decision?” helps uncover the emotional undercurrent.

2. Facilitate perceptual shifts. When you sense friction, help the team shift perspectives:

  • “Let’s pause. How might the other team feel about this proposal?”
  • “If we step back and observe ourselves as an outside stakeholder, what would we notice about how we’re approaching this?”

3. Combine data with emotional awareness. Once perspectives are expanded, reintroduce data and logic. Now, the team is more emotionally aligned and ready to engage with information objectively.

Why It Matters

In fast-moving, high-stakes environments, teams don’t just need data — they need emotional agility.

By consciously rotating through the 3 Perceptual Positions, teams make decisions that are:

  • More inclusive of emotional realities.
  • Less reactive and defensive.
  • Better balanced between intuition and analysis.

The result? More resilient decisions that stick — because they feel right and make sense.

Final Thought

As leaders and facilitators, it’s our role to help teams go beyond just “being heard” and into “truly seeing the system they’re operating within.” That’s how we turn emotionally reactive decisions into emotionally intelligent ones.

Question:

How often are your team’s “logical” decisions actually emotional ones in disguise?


Written by Asbjorn Bjaanes. Also published on Substack.

Reach out